Crisis of Sovereignty Series 08 - Hocus PCOS is commonsensical
|
| |
Emails 103 - Hocus PCOS is commonsensical
A recent headline of the Philippine Star read “Hocus PCOS, not possible”.
The last email sent by a certain Gary Hardaway to Interior and Local Government Secretary Ronaldo Puno belies this
intended balm of the Belmonte-owned newspaper, and in gruesome details at that. The newspaper was definitely adding to
the euphoria established by the first automated elections in the history of the Philippines that dished out millions of tallied
votes at lightning speed but accompanied by a thunder of doubt as to its accuracy and integrity.
Put extra careful attention to the Hardaway’s revelation in his lasy email - “without the digital signature, there is no way to tell
which machine made the second transmission…”
So where indeed did all those transmissions of returns really come from?
The first scheme created by Hardaway hacking the transmission of results to the servers was so elementary, any of our
computer-savvy children could have easily understood the simple dynamics. But not mainstream media, namely the Star, the
Philippines Daily Inquirer and ABS-CBN whose only concern is to hype the Camelot angle of the presidential candidate they
supported.
This posting reveals yet another evil plot. The second scheme tells of how another manipulation can be conducted through
the Compact Flash card, an aspect dramatized by a committee in the House of Representatives headed by Teodoro Locsin
Jr. who was more concerned about validating Comelec and Smartmatic excuses rather hearing the testimonies of Philippine
computer experts.
These experts were not at all surprised therefore when the server provided by Smartmatic to Congress received a total
transmission of 253 million votes, more than five times the total registered voters, an issue Locsin merely glossed over.
This series shows that Puno was also religiously updating President Arroyo of the developments, most especially the schemes
to be used in hacking the Automated Election System. (The following three emails have been arranged following a
chronology of thought and not time.)
Happy reading!
From: "Ronaldo V. Puno "
Subject: People need direction
To: "President G. Arroyo"
Received: Wednesday, 07 Apr 2010 11:21:38 AM
Madam,
I realize that some of our plans have not worked like we had planned. However, some of our people our
running around like headless chicken and we do need to once again assure them that the machinery has
not fallen apart. The only one who can do that would be you.
I also received yesterday the new scheme that we might be using for the coming election. However, a clear
cut decision on your part as to who we will carry down the stretch is needed. We need to discuss this at the
soonest possible time.
For your Guidance and Info.
HG101
PF: 32002 REF: 2010
Additional Manipulation Schemes (Philippines 2010 Elections)
From: "Gary Hardaway"
Subject: Other Scheme
To: "Ronaldo V. Puno "
Received: Tuesday, 06 Apr 2010
Mr. RVP,
Here is the other Scheme I mentioned to you. I came up with this but I do not highly recommend this scheme
for areas that you may consider as hotspots where too much attention will be present.
Although this scheme is very easy to put in place. It has a certain weakness. If discovered, it can easily be
proven that a deliberate attempt to cheat has taken place.
Keeping in mind the components I've discussed with you before. The basic principle that would make this
scheme run is "Manipulate the Counting Process of the PCOS. Aptly put, make the PCOS wrongly
count the votes.
Scheme Elements:
This Scheme involves a single element for implementation:
Improperly Configured CF cards - the CF cards will be loaded with an Improperly Configured Image File
and Interpretation Guide.
The CF cards will contain a valid image file but the appended Interpretation guide will be misconfigured to
make the PCOS behave in different manners based on how it was configured.
This CF card can be configured in many different ways to make the machines count the ballots in favor of a
specific candidate.
1. Configure it in such a way that Votes for a specific candidate will not be counted by defining it as "void" or
"null".
2. Make the PCOS behave in such a way that votes for one candidate will be credited to the other.
3. Configure it to behave in a way that it will reject certain Ballots although minor alterations have to be done
to the ballots itself. (Not readily available but still possible)
Note: Configuration must be given thorough consideration since it is inevitable that certain candidates will
get 0 votes for that specific PCOS.
Steps by Step Guide:
1. PCOS machines will be Initialized normally using the improperly configured CF cards.
2. Voting proceeds as Normal with voters casting their ballots in the PCOS. Since the LCD Verification is
disabled, the voters will not know that their ballot was rejected, miscounted, etc..
3. Close the PCOS normally.
4. Transmit the Data normally and Print the ER's as expected.
5. At the soonest possible time. The Tabulated data in the CF card is to be copied to a CF card with a correct
Interpretation Guide. For possible presentation later.
6. Like what we discussed over the phone. The PCOS machines will be reset immediately to zero at the first
opportunity presented as with all the other schemes.
Advantages:
1. Personalities involved in the scheme is limited only to those who will configure the CF cards.
2. The BEI and any other Officials in the Precinct can be completely unaware of the scheme without
compromising its success.
3. No jamming and Transmission failure to be staged.
4. The scheme would effectively manipulate the results even if the Digital Signature is enforced.
5. Switching of CF cards will be done after the transmission of data therefore would not be subject
to much scrutiny.
Disadvantages:
I can only foresee one major disadvantage in the scheme described above. That is, if it is discovered while
voting is going on. The erroneous Interpretation Guide in the CF card is irrevocable proof that a manipulation
conspiracy is being done. The moment one CF card is caught/discovered. You can expect that all the CF
nationwide will be subjected to scrutiny. Also, the moment this scheme is put into action,
there is no way to stop it or cancel it mid stream. Unlike the other schemes, you can easily cease operation
at any given stage.
The basic idea that was going on in my mind while formulating this scheme is this. Among all the schemes
we have prepared for, this is the only one that can circumvent the Digital Signature feature of the AES.
Besides that, I don't see any other reason why we should be employing this scheme.
If there should be any questions. Don't hesitate to call me on my private line so I can clarify immediately.
Truly. Gary.
_________________________________________________________________
From: "Ronaldo V. Puno "
Subject: As Stated
To: "President G. Arroyo"
Received: Wednesday, 07 Apr 2010 15:28:01 PM
Madam,
I have just concluded making my summary report for a possible alternative scheme for the coming election.
Although the preparations for the original scheme is in full blast. It is prudent to still have another option that
may come in handy specially right now with the highly volatile situation. I will have the report for you tomorrow
right after lunch.
Also, please pardon me for bringing this up over and over again. We need to deliberate soon as to who the
final name will be on the block for us. I have to be honest, there was a time when it was clear as to who it
should be. But things have changed dramatically as you very well know.
For you Guidance and Info.
HG101
|
| |
Crisis of Sovereignty Series 09 - GMA not Comelec controlled 2010 Elections
|
| |
Emails 104 - GMA not Comelec controlled 2010 Elections
Subtitle - Secretary Puno: "Heads will roll"
The Comelec is supposed to be a constitutional body. Yet what we read in these postings that reek of a
conspiracy of the first and highest order?
Its commissioners are not only reporting to President Arroyo with the Interior Secretary as conduit but are
following instructions from the executive branch of government including lurid details that are
self-explanatory they need no further editorializing.
Enjoy, if you can, the salaciousness of this attack on the sovereignty of the Filipino people.
SELECTED EMAILS ON CHEATERS INCORPORATED
http://cheatinginc. host-ed.net/
From: "Ronaldo V. Puno "
Subject: Precinct level Complaints
To: "Nicodemu Ferrer"
Received: Tuesday, 06 Apr 2010 16:37:42 PM
I see that you've already released the statement that the COMELEC will no longer entertain complaints on
the precinct level pertaining to document discrepancies. I know that this was part of the plan all along but I
just think that it was quite early as this could spur another attack from parties concerned.
Anyway, as a rule of thumb from now on. No statements regarding policies shall be made without first
consulting me. I hope I made myself clear.
From: "Ronaldo V. Puno "
Subject: Namfrel and the Padded List
To: "Nicodemu Ferrer"
Received: Wednesday, 07 Apr 2010 16:27:32 PM
I thought this issue about the padded list has been handled and put to rest already with the supposed
manual deletion of multiple entry names.
If so, then how come NAMFREL is at it with the press claiming that they have knowledge of a 3 Million
padding? Kontra Daya even went as far as 5 million. Once and for all, clear this matter for me and give a list
of the padded numbers and the places associated with it. I want to see if there figures are correct. If so,
where are they getting the information?
This is no joking matter, I need that report yesterday. I'm sure you know what I mean. I need them so I could
study it closely and know where we can make adjustments.
Specially now with numbers that are coming in from the surveys.
From: "Nicodemus Ferrer "
Subject: No Manual Audit until after proclamation
To: " Ronaldo V. Puno "
Received: Thursday, 15 Apr 2010 09:27:22 AM
We've convinced Melo to agree with us that no manual audit should happen before the proclamation.
It's final and we're going to announce it to the public already. Now, that should give us about 24 hours to
clean up the needed ballots and Machines. Rene and I are now making the arrangements to have the PCOS
machines be reset to zero immediately after the closing of the polls. We can do this since the Reset and
Re-zero PIN will be with the BEI's on election day.
With the machines properly reset, I don't think there is anything that could prove anything afterwards.
From: "Ronaldo V. Puno "
Subject: Final Public Test before Sealing
To: "Nicodemu Ferrer"
Received: Thursday, 15 Apr 2010 10:09:12 AM
That is good news about the manual audit. We were already thinking of the worse that Melo will order a
random audit right after the elections. Another area of concern is the final public test before the sealing the
Machines. When will this be done and what do you plan to do about this. Let me now immediately.
FYI, out of the 432 Memory Cards memory cards I got from you. So far, 360 have been copied exactly, while
all 432 already have their alternate configuration card. So I will send you 864 cards or 2 sets of 432, the ones
with the original configuration that you sent me and another set of card with alternate configuration. I'll have
them sent to you tomorrow morning.
From: "Ronaldo V. Puno "
Subject: We need more numbers
To: "Nicodemu Ferrer"
Received: Friday, 30 Apr 2010 10:16:27 AM
I think you very well know that our bet is way behind on all surveys even on our own survey. I think you can
see that for yourself and my people calculate about an 8 to 10 million edge for the other party. Now, that
number is way too big to catch even with the control we have right now. Find a way to add numbers wherever
you can get it. You have until Monday afternoon to give me a report and what is needed. I hope I made myself
clear. Meanwhile, I'll be concentrating on lowering Aquino's numbers.
From: "Nicodemus Ferrer "
Subject: Will work on the Numbers
To: " Ronaldo V. Puno "
Received: Friday, 30 Apr 2010 11:19:44 AM
I'll see what I can do. I will also ask assistance from Rene regarding the matter. Pero, If I may suggest, the
best person to talk to regarding this last minute gathering of numbers is Tagle. Sanay sya dyan at kilala nya
almost everyone. He would be a big help at this stage.
From: "Gary Hardaway"
Subject: Give me the numbers
To: "Ronaldo V. Puno "
Received: Friday, 30 Apr 2010 12:27:13 PM
Mr. RVP:
Got your SMS. Send me the figures so I can figure out what to do. That is if there is anything that can be
done. You have to understand that schemes like this are meant to augment small to medium differences but
not to recover from a major deficiency. But let me have a look first at the numbers. I'll get back to you as soon
as I look at it.
Truly.
Gary
From: "Ronaldo V. Puno "
Subject: The Report you Requested
To: "President G. Arroyo"
Received: Saturday, 01 May 2010 03:42:12 AM
Madam,
Here is the summary you asked for regarding the votes we control. However, I've marked Red the areas
where our control is mostly on the Municipal level and not the roots. I do understand your apprehension
regarding the numbers that is why I remember mentioning to you before in one of my messages that I think
it's about time that you seriously look into the last resort scenario. We do expect a major turnaround with the
numbers specially in the coming days after Gonzales comes out with the names.
You see it's no It's no longer a matter of increasing Teodoro's numbers, it's a matter of bringing down
Aquino's number that the goal now. I've attached the file containing the numbers.
For your Guidance and Info.
HG101
From: "Ronaldo V. Puno "
Subject: Correction on the Report
To: "President G. Arroyo"
Received: Saturday, 01 May 2010 11:47:22 AM
Madam,
I really have to apologize. It slipped my attention that Region III only reflected 5% total control and it was your
son who pointed it out to me. Upon reviewing the statistics, I saw that it should have read 25% total control. I
have no excuse for my lapse and I really apologize. I have attached a revised copy of the Analysis. There was
a slight improvement on the overall numbers but it still fell short of the required number. However, it is more
manageable.
For your Guidance and Info.
HG101
From: "Nicodemus Ferrer "
Subject: Unique ID for the Cards
To: " Ronaldo V. Puno "
Received: Sunday, 02 May 2010 14:04:52 PM
As I told you, the only way that we can make up that much amount of votes is to add to the number of
machines that we will control. The Editing won't be enough. A s explained to us the editing allows us to
change values only within the tolerable limit of + or -10% without triggering a system wide alert that will
certainly blow up in our faces. We nee at least 750 cards preferably around 800 just to be sure.
Here are the ID's to use:
Ballot ID 59 120 pcs
Ballot ID 61 130 pcs
Ballot ID 74 120 pcs.
Ballot ID 72 100 pcs.
Ballot ID 81 280 pcs.
Ballot ID 4 170 pcs.
This would be enough to cover that much. Hoping that our Bet's number no longer drops.
From: "Nicodemus Ferrer "
Subject: Melo won't agree
To: " Ronaldo V. Puno "
Received: Tuesday, 04 May 2010 10:32:17 AM
I have to say that probably the best option we have is to postpone the elections. We need time to sort things
out. As it is if the elections push through, were looking at a collapse of the system or worse, we would not be
able to do what we want. The big problem however is that Melo is firm that no postponement shall happen.
We may need to railroad him.
From: "Ronaldo V. Puno "
Subject: Do what is needed
To: "Nicodemu Ferrer"
Received: Tuesday, 04 May 2010 11:00:54 AM
The President doesn't care how you do it. Personally, so do I. This is your responsibility, therefore you must
fix it. Everything you needed was given and handed to you. All this mess should be clear by Friday. I warn
you, the President said, "heads will roll" if this is not fixed. As to Melo, I'll see what I can do. #
|
|
